Was this a rebuttal or a joke?

I'm having a hard time deciding.

Vox Day simply has nothing more in his repetiore than to scream "Bush Lied!" (much as the imploding Polipundit has - or the DailyKos, for that matter), and then again illustrate his point by describing the methods the Nazis used. It is, for all intents and purposes, saying that we could solve the problem by using those methods, but Mr. Day lacks the courage to say so in precisely those words.

I'm not going to pretend that I am a great and wise philosopher. All I can do is say that something doesn't look right to me, and explain why it doesn't, and let people decide for themselves. Let's just say that Mr. Day's column was called as it was seen.